Land

Mary Ann

Have you ever noticed how a sequel to a movie or book can often be a disappointment?  It is hard to keep the music playing! The sequel doesn’t quite live up to the original.  So, I was very excited when Maggie O’Farrell’s new book, Land, was published.  Hamnet, her most recent book, was a best seller and later an award-wining movie.  How do you actually follow such success?

I began reading Land and found it confusing in the first few chapters. Maybe my bad.   I wasn’t sure what O’Farrell was trying to say.  I was not hooked on the characters she introduced early on.  However, as the story unfolds, you begin to know the members of the family that are trying to eke out a living in 1865 after the Great Hunger in Ireland.  They all have interesting stories, and you become engaged with their lives. Any of us who are of Irish descent gain an understanding of how hard life was for many of our ancestors. It is amazing we are all here because life was really hard during that challenging time. 

Ireland, the land, is a major character of the story.  It reminded me of James Michener’s Hawaii.  The islands were characters, and you begin that story with their creation and how the people came to them in the following years. This is where I had some difficulty with Land. I like a good beginning, middle, and end of a story.  About half-way through Land, O’Farrell takes the reader back to the beginning of the history of Ireland.  I think this could have been a better beginning thus making the story less confusing and like Hawaii was structured.

This is not a problem of good storytelling.  O’Farrell is a gifted writer weaving interesting stories.  For me, it was about the structure.  After reading Hamnet, I couldn’t wait until her next book. Maybe I built the book up in my mind, and my expectations were too high. Frankly, I enjoyed the book, and I think you would as well.  Just be prepared it may take you a while to get into the story and the plot wanders a bit.   Hang in there, and I think it will be worth your time to read Land.